Friday, September 16, 2022

A Successful Homeschooler

I responded to a Facebook thread recently where a mother considering homeschool asked what accounts for the studies showing that Homeschooled individuals do better in most life metrics over their public schooled counterparts. (She was siting research that shows that homeschooled individuals who attend college are more likely to excel in college and all homeschooled individuals report higher satisfaction in their adult lives, here and here) She wanted to know what makes a successful homeschool, as there are examples of homeschool failure just as there are examples of public school failure, but overall why do homeschooled students do so well in their adult lives?

Here was my answer:

With the right attitude toward learning at home and good home management and structure — not the same as “school structure” — children are taught correct principles and learn to govern themselves. They have the opportunity to take ownership of their education and learning, and they develop the character and skills to be successful in any chosen path. They are given the opportunity to fail and succeed in a natural way that helps them learn that they are the agents in their own success.

They do not spend their educational years under constants supervision, over-programmed, and spoon fed information. They do not learn to rely on rubric managed assignment centric models, false comparisons, and grade structures. They have the advantage of a developmentally appropriate education that is highly personalized and paced to match their strengths and weaknesses — Public education in America is NOT developmentally appropriate, is structured on false pacing that puts pressure on students weaknesses and holds back their geniuses, and teaches intellectual dependence.

What happens in successful homeschools is not “school” but rather education and human development. Of course “school” happens as skills are learned that enable education but that is a small part of what is learned. Children also have the opportunity to learn by study and also by faith, they have more opportunities to learn that God is the source of intelligence and wisdom and through his power they can unlock their potential, enlighten their minds, and do hard things without being constantly managed by the adults around them. This creates emotionally and spiritually mature people. What happens when children learn at home is a natural extension of family life and natural development.

Couple famous quotes to ponder:

“Education is not the filling of pail but the lighting of a fire.”

“Don’t let school interfere with your education.”

“Children should be instructed in the principles of freedom.”

Why I Homeschool, And Why You Should Too!

People ask me often, why I homeschool. It’s not an easy question to answer because there are so many reasons and the question deserves a long sit down conversation, but here is my attempt to answer the question in one paragraph:

Public education in America is not developmentally appropriate, severs children from their families, is structured on false pacing that puts pressure on students’ weaknesses and holds back their geniuses, teaches intellectual dependence, destroys belief in God, does not instruct in the principles of liberty, does not model natural choice and consequence, teaches false reasoning based on false assumptions, omits important historical context for deceptive purposes, has begun to deconstruct western civilization and the philosophical and moral underpinnings of our nation, and to put the nail in the coffin the institutions can no longer keep children safe from bullying, sexual exploitation, or violent crime.

“All experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.”

When will we reach the point when our government schools are unsufferable in their design to reduce us to absolute despotism? And will we the people have the cuttings to throw off these institutions and provide new guards for our children? We must do it soon, for as Abraham Lincoln so astutely observed, “The school room in one generation is the government in the next.”

Why Testing is Not Necessary in Elementary School

A question homeschool parents are often asked by curious friends and family and teacher friends is, "How do you know if your child is learning?" This question assumes that a teacher needs regular tests to assess a students progress, and of course most homeschooled students don't take regular tests and usually no standardized tests. Here's how I answer this question:

Public schools in the United States use tests to gauge the progress of students because teachers have to track over a dozen students (most classes having over 20 students) at one time — in an environment that makes it impossible for teachers to have one-on-one time to assess their students in a observational way. Observational assessment is a more meaningful way to access progress than standardized testing, but it can only be done when teachers are engaged in more interactive types of instructional methods — and take the time to observe students individually.

Testing in the public school way is not helpful to the development of young children. In has a negative impact on a child's development that is not worth the data derived from it — and high-stakes standardized testing, done every year in US schools, is particularly harmful. In Finland, where the education system is developmentally appropriate, teachers use healthy models of interactive instruction & observation. Students don't take their first standardized test until 8th grade, and in early elementary assessments are observation based, not formal tests. This school system ranks at the top in international tests given to their students in 10th grade.

Homeschool parents use the most healthy and effective form of observational assessment to mark the progress of their children. They do not need regular tests or intensive standardized testing to know their children are learning and developing academically. The intuitive teaching and learning relationship between a parent and their child as they homeschool is powerful and homeschool parents have a better understanding of their child's strengths and weaknesses, knowledge and deficits, than standard tests are able to reveal in their public school counterparts.

Most homeschooled students begin taking standard quizzes and tests, though, not necessarily standardized tests, in 7th or 8th grade, and they are often doing more standardized curriculum and courses complete with standard tests in their high school years. In most cases homeschool families find this adequate preparation for college entry testing and college preparation. Homeschoolers are proving that early frequent testing is not only unnecessary but developmentally inappropriate.

Thursday, August 19, 2021

Stop the Homeschool Fights & Instill Independence in Your Child's Learning

Everyday there are questions posted in homeschool groups across the country from homeschool parents just starting out or struggling to keep going. Many of the question are repeated over and over by different parents and it's hard for veteran homeschool moms like me to find the time to mentor very many by constantly answering those questions. I want to answer. I want to help, but there are just too many people asking.

This frustration has increased this past year as so many parents found themselves homeschooling during COVID and now that schools are opening again there are many who are choosing to continue homeschooling. I've decided to start a series of blog posts that answer questions that are regularly asked by new homeschool parents in these online groups. I hope these blog posts will help me to mentor more struggling homeschool parents than I otherwise would have the time to respond to.

My first subject should cover many variations of the same question.

HOW DO I STOP THE FIGHTS OVER GETTING SCHOOL WORK DONE?

Joke!

First of all, it's important for me to tell you that all homeschooling parents are struggling in one way or another to find what works best for their child (children). Choosing the right teaching methods and curriculums that best fit each child and the family culture is a trial and error process in itself. Forming the right home and school management system is as important as methods and curriculums, and really it must come first, which is why I'm taking up this topic first.

Today in a Facebook group a mother posted: "Today's first day of homeschool freaking sucked! My daughter... was fighting me all day and it's continuing into the evening with her being out of control. Her mind constantly wanders too, something that would normally take a few minutes takes half an hour. What has helped your child have a much more successful day? And how do you stay patient when your child is throwing a tantrum every 5 minutes? I tried being patient today but you can only hold so much patience."

DISCLAIMERS:

First of all, before I answer this question, let me say that what I’m going to recommend in answer to this question is the kind of structure that children are usually not ready for until 7 years old. Before 7 school should be play based with very little direct instruction. Routines, but not necessarily structure, should rule the pre-K and early ED management. There is no reason to set requirements for daily curriculums before age 7. I've written a blog post on early childhood education and what is developmentally appropriate. If you are struggling the way this mom is with a very young child, even a 7 year old, you need to STOP, step back, and change your approach to education. Early ED (4-8) is a completely different kind of education then the kind of structure and direct instruction that comes later. See my post on developmentally appropriate education here.

Also, if your child has behavioral and learning challenges please consider whether or not your child might be dyslexic or have other neurodiverse learning challenges. Dyslexia can be caught young if you know what it is and how to look for it and it is the number one learning challenge for human beings with 20% of humans having dyslexic brains. Here is my post on the subject of dyslexia. My youngest is profoundly dyslexic and some of the challenges we have faced in education are because of his dyslexia, however, the answer to the question I will give has worked wonderfully for him and learning challenges should never be an excuse not to teach a child to self-govern.

Teaching Self-Government and Instilling Independence in your Child's Learning

What has worked for me is to realize I wasn’t going to get anywhere with my son if I was constantly in the supervisory role. If it was my program, my way, then it would be a constant fight. That is exactly how school was going for me with my youngest from about the age of 8 when I started a more structured school curriculum and direct instruction. It so happened that this was also the age that I began to suspect that my son was dyslexic and needed more intensive systematic reading instruction.

I rode my son constantly. I felt like I had made myself his school jailer and was driving myself and him insane. The worst part was that I knew I was destroying our relationship. Thanks to a very good friend and a homeschool mentor of mine, I made a major philosophy switch in my head and turned his education over to him in some key ways. It was terrifying at first and there were some almost funny fits that ensued (funny now, not then).

Inspired by my friend who is the mother of ten and had years of homeschool experience under her belt, I found a way to put my son in charge of his education and still retain a good amount of structure, which I need and I also believe is very good for my son. I created a weekly planning sheet that had vertical columns for each school day and three horizontal sections for different categories of daily tasks.

The weekly planner sheet includes the daily essentials and other good and worthwhile personal pursuits. My requirement was to do everything in the essentials category, everyday, unless excused by mom for some reason. Then, to choose at least two a day in the other category. When he completes his planning sheet then his time is all his own for the rest of the day. — Family rules and standards still in force, of course!

The best category includes all the daily essentials including duties to God, family (family chores), and self care (personal care and chores). It includes all curriculum work in reading, writing, and arithmetic; and when they graduate to middle and high school daily work in history and science are added. The other category includes academics that aren't necessary as everyday subjects during elementary ED such as science, history, creative arts, and P.E. and a list of creative things kids can and should do everyday for their personal development. It includes art, developing a talent, personal reading for pleasure, play inside or out, build something, engaging in a family activity, field trips and outings, and/or serving someone.

(My weekly planning sheet template can viewed here. )

These weekly planning sheets were in a clip board hung in the homeschool area where he could see and use them daily. Each day he would use a highlighter to highlight each box as he completed them. He could choose to do them in any order and he made his own choices about when to start school and how to finish it. He knew he must do everything in the must do box to have any freedom at all (which to my son really means screen time because that’s what he wants). But completing the essentials got him only so much screen time (when he was younger), to get total freedom — meaning his time is his time without mom managing him — he had to complete options in the "other" section of the sheet, the purpose here is to be sure he was spending some of his time everyday in personal development beyond his academic requirements.

When my son completed the entire daily planning sheet, we began calling it a 100% day. A 100% day meant maximum freedom over his time and maximum trust from his parents. If not, he got no screen time/video games and no special activities or friends over. He could of course free-play all he wanted but none of the other stuff.

Now here’s the hard part. I had to let him fail quite a lot at first and hold to the consequences through the fits that ensued. I made it clear that I would not instruct him unless he was calm and respectful toward me as his teacher. If he threw a fit during teacher instruction time, I simply closed the book and said calmly, "You are not ready to be instructed, I'll come back when you are ready." He didn’t make wise choices at first. He planned poorly and didn’t get everything done plenty of times, and then was angry with me when he didn't earn his screen time. A few times he choose to do nothing at all — and I had to watch him do it... let him do it… thinking “Oh no! My child isn’t getting an education!!” — But I stuck to it.

I found myself befuddled when instead of us fighting as we used too -- me pushing him to get this and that done on my time table, and the fits he would throw during instruction time -- he was instead yelling at me to “get back here” when I calmly walked away, or he'd say he wanted “his other mom back” when I would say, “It’s your education, you decide how your going to get it done.” It was painful for the first few weeks — rocky for a month or so — and then the miracle happened. My son began doing his work. At first, just the must do section for a little screen time he desperately missed and wanted to earn. Then more and more. Till he was doing 100% days nearly every day.

What I found was that when my son did all of the sections each day it took a good school day to complete, and therefore, he was spending most of his time in worthy pursuit and personal development. I felt better about our structure and his accomplishment and progress and he began learning how to prioritize his time and be a self-driven learner.

Over the months he even learned that the order of subjects I had used when I was managing things was the best way (hard stuff first thing in the morning, then everything else) and he began choosing to do it that way all on his own. Over the years since I’ve made this change he has become a self-starter. He picks up his daily agendas and gets to work, he plans his instructional times with me around my schedule, he gets his work done earlier in the day realizing that if he doesn’t procrastinate he has more time for the things he enjoys. He values his freedom and his autonomy — don’t we all!

Now that he is in high-school his reward and consequence structure is different, in that I don't dole out screen-time by the "hours" per his achievement. Now he works for the privilege of adult like autonomy in our home, with the exception of some hard clad family standards over media content. What he wants is not to be controlled by his parents and be allowed to manage his own time and bed-time. For this we developed a new phased system for earning and losing privileges based on demonstrating mature character traits.

The beauty of homeschool is that your child can learn to learn independently, they can learn to be self directed, to manage their education, to take control of their own lives. It’s marvelous preparation for real life and far superior to the constant supervision and coddling they get in public school. To do it you must turn it over to them, make them responsible, set the expectations, create the structure and house rules, but stop fighting with them about it. Stop micromanaging everything. Take this leap and you will transform your homeschool.

Wednesday, October 28, 2020

Teaching Self Government is Essential to Sustaining Free Societies

 This past month we had the privilege to participate in the semi-annual general conference of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The speakers at the conference delivered two straight days of uplifting sermons that were extremely poignant to meet the concerns of our challenging times. The speakers at the conference clearly reacted to the trying social conditions that are raging around us and gave important counsel for the relief of social ills threatening our peace.


Elder D. Todd Christofferson spoke to the immense importance of adherence to time tested and divinely given principles in the sustaining and flourishing of human society. He said, “The concept of sustainable development is an interesting and important one. Even more urgent, however, is the broader question of sustainable societies… Sustainability is not guaranteed, and a thriving society can fail in time if it abandons the cardinal virtues that uphold its peace and prosperity.”


It is the connection between sustainable free societies and teaching our children to adhere to principles that uphold that peace and prosperity that I would like to focus on this month. Specifically I would like to focus on the need to practice and teach self-governance, both at home and at school. Many of you may be familiar with the author and speaker Nicholeen Peck and her book, “A House United; Changing Children’s Hearts and Behaviors by Teaching Self Government,” but if you are not I highly recommend her work to you. Nicholeen Peck has provided countless parents the structure and tools to better practice and teach self-government in the home and as such has changed many lives for the better. In her book Nichileen Peck said:

“The time for strong families is now. The world around us is complicated and depraved. Our homes need to be refuge from the storms which rage around us and our children. I want my home to give all who enter the feeling of warmth, peace, strength and courage to face the challenges of our times. I want my home to give a message to the world. I want people to see something different in my family than they see in the rest of the world. Not only does a home like this strengthen my family, a home like this strengthens many families in the world around us.” To have this kind of home Nicholeen Peck teaches that each person in the family must be responsible for governing his or her own behaviors and emotions. This is the kind of self-discipline that leads to self-government.”

Self government is: being able to determine the cause and effect of any given situation and possessing a knowledge of your own behaviors so that you can control them. 

If you teach a child how to govern his own behaviors, you will teach him how to change his heart. This change of heart is more important than any behavior change. This change of heart and change of behavior based on divinely given principles is the only real power there is on earth to sustain families and by extension free societies. Latter-day Saints should be particularly acquainted with the principles of self-governance. When I think of this critical principle of sustainable liberty I often think of the long ago story of Joseph Smith, recounted by John Taylor, the third President of the Church. He reported: “Some years ago, in Nauvoo, a gentleman in my hearing, a member of the Legislature, asked Joseph Smith how it was that he was enabled to govern so many people, and to preserve such perfect order; remarking at the same time that it was impossible for them to do it anywhere else. Mr. Smith remarked that it was very easy to do that. ‘How?’ responded the gentleman; ‘to us it is very difficult.’ Mr. Smith replied, ‘I teach them correct principles, and they govern themselves.’”

A lesser known account from Brigham Young, the second President of the Church, reported: “The question was asked a great many times of Joseph Smith, by gentlemen who came to see him and his people, ‘How is it that you can control your people so easily? It appears that they do nothing but what you say; how is it that you can govern them so easily?’ Said he, ‘I do not govern them at all. The Lord has revealed certain principles from the heavens by which we are to live in these latter days. The time is drawing near when the Lord is going to gather out His people from the wicked, and He is going to cut short His work in righteousness, and the principles which He has revealed I have taught to the people and they are trying to live according to them, and they control themselves.’”

It was this personal allegiance to God given law that Elder Christofferson spoke of at this last conference. He warned of the consequences to our society when people turn from a sense of accountability to God and abandon the institutions of the family and religion. “When one has no higher god than himself and seeks no greater good than satisfying his own appetites and preferences, the effects will be manifest in due course.” 

Edmund Burke (1729-1797), is rightly renowned as the father of conservatism, Burke Championed "Ordered Liberty" a philosophy which relied on the rule of law governed by the moral restraints of the individual, he said it this way: “But what is liberty without wisdom and without virtue? It is the greatest of all possible evils; for it is folly, vice, and madness, without tuition or restraint.” We live at a time when our children are constantly being taught by the world to throw off moral precepts, to askew personal responsibility and accountability, to doubt the wisdom of age-old commitments to chastity before marriage and fidelity in marriage, and to misunderstand the indispensable relationship between virtue and liberty.

Increasingly voices in our society champion freedom of choice without any expectation of constraint. They talk about freedom as a matter of choice without consequences. There is an expectation that social safety net programs will provide individuals with relief from debauchery and never discriminate against personal choice, essentially subsidizing dysfunctional and dangerous personal conduct that tears apart the fabric of family. Individual freedom has become a twisted virtue that turns a blind eye to the pornification of our culture, supports legalized prostitution, drugs, and any sexual deviancy imaginable. Americans seem to have decided that what goes on in a persons’ private life has no sway on their public ethos. I avow that there can be no separation between private morality and public character. What goes on behind closed doors sends shock waves through our families, culture, and institutions.

Burke did not place individual liberty as high as to be untempered by the law and the moral restraint of society. Burke argued that these abstract rights are extreme and unrealistic as they provided that men were free to act anywhere according to their pleasure, without any moral tie. He denied that such rights ever existed. 

“Men have a right to live by that rule; they have a right to justice.... They have a right to the fruits of their industry; and to the means of making their industry fruitful. They have a right to the acquisitions of their parents; to the nourishment and improvement of their offspring; to instruction in life, and to consolation in death... But liberty is not license to act from sheer self-will. Rather, it is “social freedom."

In an article titled, “Behold, the Enemy Is Combined”. Neal A. Maxwell asked, “How can there possibly be a disturbing loss of individual impulse control without a corresponding loss of collective freedom?” He cited historian Will Durant’s warning that “If the hunger for liberty destroys order, the hunger for order will destroy liberty.” He went on to say that “while I would not shrink the circumference of freedom, the size of that circle is not the sole measure of social well-being. Hence, to exult, as some do, over how much decadence is permissible at the edges ignores the erosive effects of such grossness upon all within that circle.”

The world is preoccupied with the pollution of our physical environment and completely unconcerned about the harm done by the pollution of our moral environment. Which is the more pressing danger facing the sustainment of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness? It’s uncomfortable to be expected to govern one’s self and to rein in personal freedom for the guarantee of collective freedom, however It is incumbent upon us to spend our lives in the pursuit of it, to sacrifice our comfort in obedience to it, and to be willing to lay down our lives in the protection of it.

Burke taught that to be fit for freedom, people need self-control and morality. “Men are qualified for civil liberty, in exact proportion to their disposition to put moral chains upon their own appetites; in proportion as their love of justice is above their rapacity; in proportion as their soundness and sobriety of understanding is above their vanity and presumption; in proportion as they are more disposed to listen to the counsels of the wise and good, in preference to the flattery of knaves. Men of intemperate minds cannot be free. Their passions forge their fetters.”

The family is the single greatest antidote to the poison in our world. It is therefore in the inculcating of divine virtue and true principles of human conduct in our homes that our primary energy must be applied. It is in the training our children receive at home that they will learn to bridle their passions and develop the wisdom of temperate and dedicated self-governance. In so stating I do not wish to diminish our role and responsibility to defend principles of truth in the public square or engage in critical work to strengthen institutions of government, education, or culture. Clearly if we retreat into our homes and leave the public institutions to decay we will find in short order that even our homes are no longer safe from the advancing forces of evil in our world, but our community role is a topic for another article. 

My purpose today is to emphasize the importance of religion and the institution of the family for the purpose of endowing both individuals and communities with the virtues that sustain an enduring free society. As Nicholeen Peck observed that, “Not only does a home like this strengthen my family, a home like this strengthens many families in the world around us.” As we attend to this critical teaching, may we apply the principles of agency in harmony with God’s plan and give our children the room to develop personal responsibility through agency and accountability. It is my hope that we will realize the importance of teaching self-governance to our children and view it as our greatest contribution to the strengthening and sustaining of our free republic.


*I highly recommend Nicholeen Peck’s book as a guide to the teaching of self-governance in the home. You can find her books here.